Review - Elvis Today FTD CD
Source: Elvis In Norway
September 30, 2005 - 10:28:00 AM
Elvis Reviews, Elvis CD Reviews, FTD
CD-1 contains the original masters in their familiar mix.
First out is take 1 of 'Fairytale', which is a 1:20 long false start. It just stops, like the tape ran out... Take 2 was already made available on Great Country Songs many years ago. It still is a smashing take, in my point of view.
Take 1 of 'Bringin' It Back' contains a very prominent acoustic guitar, and even some less lucky chords. While take 3, first found on 6363 Sunset almost was a carbon copy of the master take, Elvis really approach a different timing on this take 1. An interesting outtake, indeed!
Take 1 of 'Shake A Hand' finds Elvis almost losing his voice several places.
Take 2, first found on 6363 Sunset is slightly better, though both a sub-par compared to the master!
Take 3 of 'Susan When She Tried' is not far from what the master became. Take 2 of 'Pieces Of My Life' is a false start. Elvis simply says 'No...no' after 35 seconds. The following take 3 is a good take. Done in the same way as the other takes we have of this song. There is a slight mic overload on Elvis' vocal on this track.
Here we get the forth take of 'And I Love You So'. This take 3 is really no different than the rest we have.
CD-2 contains the first mix down made by Felton Jarvis and Rick Ruggeri.
When Elvis heard them, he was so dissatisfied with Duke Bardwell's bass line that he ordered it replaced. The master takes were then sent for overdubbing of a new bass (done by Mike Leech this time). Later other instruments, chorus etc. were overdubbed, in true Felton Jarvis style...!
These rough mixes offers quite little, actually. I had hoped for a more noticeable difference. However, if nothing else, we at least now have the undubbed masters. 'Fairytale' comes out better in undubbed format, I think. I have a feeling that Elvis might have been truly disappointed after listening to 'I Can Help' for the first time. It contains a slight error by James Burton at the start and a generally uninspiring guitar line. In addition to a clumsy bass, 'I Can Help' sounds like a different take when presented in this undubbed format.
At the end of 'Susan When She Tried' you can hear one of the backup singers do a mistake, which almost brings Elvis out in laughter. But he managed to stay focused all the way to the end. I think that most people will agree that 'Woman Without Love' is better 'as-is', in other words without all the overdubs Felton Jarvis added. In general these undubbed takes display Glen Hardin's piano playing better. Almost always a plus!
The CD is presented in the more and more common, yet stylish way. We get adequate information from the sessions and the time around. Several nice photos from Elvis on stage have been used. The reproduction of the original albums backside, introduce an embarrassing error, however... Susan when She Said!?
In general this double CD is a nice addition to the Elvis collection.
I found it interesting to hear these rough mixes, although they provided less 'news' than I hoped for. As for outtakes, I would rate take 1 of 'Bringin' It Back' as the highlight. This is a true outtake, where Elvis times the phrasing quite differently than on the master. The sound quality is ok all the way, but I think that some of these masters would have benefited from a totally new mixing from scratch. However, it looks like this is not economically viable on the FTD label. It has been done earlier, on Viva Las Vegas with splendid result and on Live From Memphis, but in general I believe that such efforts will be done on the main label, if ever.
Buy Elvis Today
Elvis Today - Elvis Presley FTD CD
Disc 1: T-R-O-U-B-L-E; And I Love You So; Susan When She Tried; Woman Without Love; Shake A Hand; Pieces Of My Life; Fairytale; I Can Help; Bringin'' It Back; Green, Green Grass Of Home; Outtakes: Tiger Man; And I Love You So - take 2; Pieces Of My Life – take 1; Fairytale - takes 1,2; Bringin'' It Back - take 1; Green, Green Grass Of Home - take 1; Shake A Hand - take 1; Susan When She Tried - take 3; Pieces Of My Life - takes 2,3; And I Love You So - take 3
Disc 2 Original Session Mixes: Fairytale; Green, Green Grass Of Home; I Can Help; And I Love You So; Susan When She Tried; T-R-O-U-B-L-E; Woman Without Love; Shake A Hand; Bringin'' It Back ; Pieces Of My Life; 6363 Sunset Material: Green, Green Grass Of Home - takes 2,3; Susan When She Tried - takes 1,2; And I Love You So - take 1; Bringin' It Back - takes 2,3; T-R-O-U-B-L-E - take 1; Shake A Hand - take 2
Tupelo's Own Elvis Presley DVD + 16 page booklet.
Never before have we seen an Elvis Presley concert from the 1950's with sound. Until Now! The DVD Contains recently discovered unreleased film of Elvis performing 6 songs, including Heartbreak Hotel and Don't Be Cruel, live in Tupelo Mississippi 1956. Included we see a live performance of the elusive Long Tall Sally seen here for the first time ever.
This is an excellent release no fan should be without it.
The 'parade' footage is good to see as it puts you in the right context with color and b&w footage. The interviews of Elvis' Parents are well worth hearing too. The afternoon show footage is wonderful and electrifying : Here is Elvis in his prime rocking and rolling in front of 11.000 people. Highly recommended.