Review : So High FTD CD
February 1, 2004
Elvis Reviews, Elvis CD Reviews, FTD, By David Adams
First up we have Run On - take 6. Here we get a perfect stereo take, which is complete. The only other complete alternate take of this song on FTD's 'Easter Special' but I don't think we'll get the incomplete takes released officially. It's very close to the master (take 7) and the only significant difference I can hear is where Elvis sings 'that's all brother you'll knock no more, well run on …' after the last verse.
Stand By Me - take 6 is next, but what we actually get is take 2. To make things even more confusing, we have take 2 listed on FTD's 'Easter Special' where in fact we got take 6!!! Confused? I certainly was. We've had the odd takes of this song in mono before on bootleg sets. The only other complete take apart from the master (take 11), take 10 was released on the 'Close Up' box set from BMG.
Down In The Alley - take 6 sounds great and is in stereo in near perfect sound quality but no matter how many times I listen to it I just can't distinguish it from the master (take 9).
Tomorrow Is A Long Time is one of those songs that I could play over and over again and not get tired of it, so to get take 2 in this quality is a real thrill to hear. This is the only complete take of the song apart from the master (take 4). Love Letters - take 8 is very close to the master (take 9).
So High - take 1 has been released before in mono, but it's great to finally get it in this sound quality.
We had takes 2 and 3 on FTD's 'Easter Special' (listed as take 2) so we now have the complete session officially released, apart from the count in before the master (take 4). At the beginning of the take it sounds like Felton Jarvis says 'okay this is So High take one, swing on…' and from then on Elvis certainly does, and for a first take of the song Elvis is very together with it. We got take 4 of By And By on FTD's 'Long Lonely Highway' and here we get take 9 here in perfect sound quality and it's very close to the master (take 10) apart from Elvis' little laugh just before he sings '…well children, by and by …' on the last verse.
Somebody Bigger Than You And I is one of my favourite religious songs. Here we get take 11 in stereo and the only real difference I can hear is Elvis not quite hitting the high note on 'will never die …' at the end of the song. BMG has released other complete takes on 'Easter Special' (take 12) and 'Close Up' (take 15), but we are still to get take 16 which was used for the spliced master along with work part - take 6, maybe one day.
Without Him (take 1) is another beautiful song and if it wasn't for the squeak at the beginning and in the middle of the song, it sounds great. We've had take 8 released by BMG on 'Close Up' and take 12 is the master. This is one of those songs where Elvis tried to do a better take after the master, so we still have a complete take 14 to look forward to from BMG in the future.
Next up we get take 6 of If The Lord Wasn't Walking By My Side, and it's unusual, as I said earlier, to get a take of a song after the master (take 5) but I guess they tried to do a better take to be considered the master, but then stuck with take 5. We had this with I'm Gonna Walk Dem Golden Stairs, where takes 2 and 3 were released on FTD's 'Easter Special' and then take 5 was released on FTD's 'Fame And Fortune'. How many of us expected those takes? Especially when the master is take 1.
We finally got the stereo master (take 8) of Come What May on FTD's 'Long Lonely Highway', before then it had only been released in mono so BMG have only recently located the stereo master in the last few years. Maybe that's why they used take 7 on the '60's box' and Tomorrow Is A Long Time instead of the master.
I'll Remember You (overdub take 2) is another truly beautiful song that has only been released previously in mono on bootleg. It's welcome to finally get in stereo and in great sound quality, and the ending has a haunting feeling to it the way Elvis' voice fades back in the mix, truly wonderful.
Guitar Man - take 9 is totally new to us, as only takes 1 to 6 have been released on bootleg, as well as take 5 ('Platinum') and take 10 ('Long Lonely Highway') by BMG. This take seems to be sung more laid back than the master (take 12).
Mine - take 4 has been released before on There's Always Me Vol 4 along with take 3 (Long False Start) and take 8(a), which is just an instrumental, but take 4 is presented here in better sound quality than has been released before. As this is the first complete take of the song, Elvis just doesn't seem at ease with the song yet, and it shows a little. We've also had take 9 (listed as takes 8 and 9) by BMG on 'Close Up'. It's actually funny to listen to take 8(b) as Felton forgets to turn Elvis' mike back on for the take (which is unreleased) and that's how we get Elvis' comments about an album of instrumentals before take 9 on 'Close Up'.
Singing Tree - take 1 (September 11 1967) is another new take released for the first time here. We got take 4 released by BMG on 'Close Up', and the master (take 13) was released on FTD's 'Long Lonely Highway'. For the first take of the song Elvis seems really at ease with the song, although the backing singers don't. This, to me is a very underrated song that was tucked away as a bonus song on the Clambake LP, and it's great to hear the song as it was originally recorded, without Elvis' harmony vocal overdubbed.
Just Call Me Lonesome is another song where the master was delivered in just one take, but Elvis went on recording more takes to see if he could improve on it.
Here we get takes 3 and 4 to go with take 6 which was released in mono on the bootleg and then by BMG in stereo on 'Great Country Songs'. Takes 3 (2 short false starts) and 4 are totally unreleased until now, and sound very different to the master as Elvis is trying a different arrangement. This arrangement works well until the musicians seem to mess up on the break just before Elvis sings the last verse.
Another totally unreleased take here for the first time is High Heel Sneakers - take 5, and it runs for just under 5 minutes. It's a real thrill to listen to but doesn't really sound much different to the unedited master. Elvis seems very loose with the song throughout, but it fades at the end when Elvis starts to stumble on some of the lyrics. We've had the unedited master (take 7) along with a snippet of take 6 on the '60's box' from BMG, which runs for 4 minutes 33 seconds, and I've been told that a 5 minute version of the master is on the cassette release of 'Elvis Aron Presley' (Silver Box) but not having it, cannot confirm this. The master on the CD version of 'Elvis Aron Presley' runs for 2 minutes 47 seconds.
You Don't Know Me - take 2 is another totally new take to us, as we only have take 1 released on the Japanese CD set 'We Love Elvis Vol 2. The spliced master is all that has been released by BMG. This is one of those songs that were wasted in the movie Clambake in my opinion, along with The Girl I Never Loved.
We Call On Him - take 2. Another very underrated song in my opinion.
We've had take 2 of You'll Never Walk Alone from BMG on the 'Platinum' box, but here we get the unreleased complete take 1, which runs for nearly 5 and a half minutes, and it's also a thrill to listen to. The master is actually spliced from this take and take 8, so maybe one day we'll get take 8 released uncut too.
Most of us have heard the Yodel (Jam) that is in between takes 2 and 3 of Stay Away on bootleg but it's released officially here for the first time albeit still only in mono. The actual title of the jam is 'Muleskinner Blues'.
Next we get take 6 of Stay Away and this has been released before on bootleg but only in mono. There are actually another 4 complete takes of this song to be released officially but to me they all sound the same. The overdubs, however, by Jerry Reed, do sound decidedly different, but these are still of now, unreleased.
US Male - take 11 is very similar to the master (take 12) but again, we've only had this before in mono on bootleg. The other complete takes we've had from BMG, take 7 was on 'Today Tomorrow And Forever' and take 10 was on 'Close Up'. I don't think we'll ever get to hear the jam (Prisoners Song) between takes 1 and 2 officially, as it can be took to be slightly offensive!
During the Too Much Monkey Business session, we get to hear some pre-song banter between Elvis and the guys before take 4, and we get a snippet of Elvis singing 'When Irish Eyes Are Smiling' as well as Elvis joking with Jerry Reed about the song 'Tupelo Mississippi Flash' (I really wonder what Elvis was on that day!) very funny to listen to. Then we get take 10 of Too Much Monkey Business, which is sung slower, but punchier than the master (take 5). We also had take 9 on FTD's 'Long Lonely Highway' sung in the same style.
Going Home - take 29 is another take released for the first time here, although we have had takes 21 and 22 from BMG on 'Collectors Gold'. We've had most of the last part of this session in pretty bad sound on Bootleg, but the tape is cut in places and it's hard to work out what takes are what. It gets even more confusing when Felton announces take 28 after take 25, so we really don't know what takes are what. Presumably the master is take 28, so this must have been sung after the master, although it's very similar.
This is another essential addition to any fans collection, especially if like me; you love to hear studio sessions and alternate takes. So highly recommended, make this a must for your collection.
Buy So High
In the last twelve years or so RCA/BMG began to realise that Elvis fans weren't interested in hearing the same old songs any more, we wanted more. But how could they give us what we wanted? Elvis had been dead for 14 years and wasn't going to record any new songs, and it was getting less and less likely that any new or lost songs would be found. The answer was sitting right under their noses, in the reels and reels of recording sessions they had. Up until 'Collectors Gold' in 1991 we had the odd alternate take released, and were thrilled to hear them, but nothing on the scale of 'Collectors Gold', and it must have been then BMG realised that they could release these 'New' alternate takes, and keep the fans happy at the same time. Since 1999 when BMG founded their very own Collectors Label, to try and counteract the bootleggers, we have had an influx of new material spread over 25 regular releases now, ranging from Home Recordings, Rehearsals, Soundboards and of course Studio Sessions. In fact 11 of FTD's regular releases have had studio sessions with alternate takes on them, and we've had quite a few gems amongst them, and those don't include the new Soundtracks from FTD which also include some new alternate takes. I don't know how long BMG can quench our thirst for new material, as it seems to be getting to the point now where we are expecting new releases every few months or so, and not just hoping for them. I myself am guilty of this, and I know most of you will be too. I know I'm not alone when I say here's to the next 25 Follow That Dream releases, and long may they continue.
So High - Elvis Presley CD
Tracklisting : Run On -take 6 2:27; Stand By Me - take 2 2:41; Down In The Alley - take 6 2:48 ; Tomorrow Is A Long Time - take 2 5:50 ; Love Letters - take 8 3:12 ; So High - take 1 2:12 ; By And By - take 9 2:01; Somebody Bigger Than You And I - take 11 2:36 ; Without Him - take 1 2:55 ; If The Lord Wasn't Walking By My Side - take 6 1:39 ; Come What May - take 2 1:53 ; I'll Remember You - take 2 4:10 ; Guitar Man – take 9 2:31 ;Mine - take 4 3:03 ; Singing Tree - take 1 3:04 ; Just Call Me Lonesome - takes 3,4 2:19 ; Hi-Heel Sneakers - take 5 4:54 ; You Don't Know Me - take 2 2:48 ;We Call On Him - take 2 2:36 ; You'll Never Walk Alone - take 1 5:26 ; Jam 0:26 ; Stay Away - take 6 2:22 ; U.S. Male - take 11 3:00 ; Too Much Monkey Business - takes 4, 10 4:20 ; Going Home - take 29 2:28.
Tupelo's Own Elvis Presley DVD + 16 page booklet.
Never before have we seen an Elvis Presley concert from the 1950's with sound. Until Now! The DVD Contains recently discovered unreleased film of Elvis performing 6 songs, including Heartbreak Hotel and Don't Be Cruel, live in Tupelo Mississippi 1956. Included we see a live performance of the elusive Long Tall Sally seen here for the first time ever.
This is an excellent release no fan should be without it.
The 'parade' footage is good to see as it puts you in the right context with color and b&w footage. The interviews of Elvis' Parents are well worth hearing too. The afternoon show footage is wonderful and electrifying : Here is Elvis in his prime rocking and rolling in front of 11.000 people. Highly recommended.